Barak DovIsrael Institute of Biological Research PO Box 19, Ness-Ziona 70450 IsraelPhone : 972-8-938-1529 Fax : 972-8-940-1404 Send E-Mail to Barak Dov
Title: Accommodation of physostigmine and its analogues by acetylcholinesterase is dominated by hydrophobic interactions Barak D, Ordentlich A, Stein D, Yu QS, Greig NH, Shafferman A Ref: Biochemical Journal, 417:213, 2009 : PubMed
The role of the functional architecture of the HuAChE (human acetylcholinesterase) in reactivity toward the carbamates pyridostigmine, rivastigmine and several analogues of physostigmine, that are currently used or considered for use as drugs for Alzheimer's disease, was analysed using over 20 mutants of residues that constitute the interaction subsites in the active centre. Both steps of the HuAChE carbamylation reaction, formation of the Michaelis complex as well as the nucleophilic process, are sensitive to accommodation of the ligand by the enzyme. For certain carbamate/HuAChE combinations, the mode of inhibition shifted from a covalent to a noncovalent type, according to the balance between dissociation and covalent reaction rates. Whereas the charged moieties of pyridostigmine and rivastigmine contribute significantly to the stability of the corresponding HuAChE complexes, no such effect was observed for physostigmine and its analogues, phenserine and cymserine. Moreover, physostigmine-like ligands carrying oxygen instead of nitrogen at position -1 of the tricyclic moiety (physovenine and tetrahydrofurobenzofuran analogues) displayed comparable structure-function characteristics toward the various HuAChE enzymes. The essential role of the HuAChE hydrophobic pocket, comprising mostly residues Trp(86) and Tyr(337), in accommodating (-)-physostigmine and in conferring approximately 300-fold stereoselectivity toward physostigmines, was elucidated through examination of the reactivity of selected HuAChE mutations toward enantiomeric pairs of different physostigmine analogues. The present study demonstrates that certain charged and uncharged ligands, like analogues of physostigmine and physovenine, seem to be accommodated by the enzyme mostly through hydrophobic interactions.
Functional architecture of the AChE active center appears to be characterized by both structural "rigidity", necessary to stabilize the catalytic triad as well as by flexibility in accommodating the different, high affinity AChE ligands. These seemingly conflicting structural properties of the active center are demonstrated through combination of structural methods with kinetic studies of the enzyme and its mutant derivatives with plethora of structurally diverse ligands and in particular with series of stereoselective covalent and noncovalent AChE ligands. Thus, steric perturbation of the acyl pocket precipitates in a pronounced stereoselectivity toward methylphosphonates by disrupting the stabilizing environment of the catalytic histidine rather than through steric exclusion demonstrating the functional importance of the "rigid" environment of the catalytic machinery. The acyl pocket, the cation-binding subsite (Trp86) and the peripheral anionic subsite were also found to be directly involved in HuAChE stereoselectivity toward charged chiral phosphonates, operating through differential positioning of the ligand cationic moiety within the active center. Residue Trp86 is also a part of the "hydrophobic patch" which seems flexible enough to accommodate the structurally diverse ligands like tacrine, galanthamine and the two diastereomers of huperzine A. Also, we have recently discovered further aspects of the role of both the unique structure and the flexibility of the "hydrophobic patch" in determining the reactivity and stereoselectivity of HuAChE toward certain carbamates including analogs of physostigmine. In these cases the ligands are accommodated mostly through hydrophobic interactions and their stereoselectivity delineates precisely the steric limits of the pocket. Hence, the HuAChE stereoselectivity provides a sensitive tool in the in depth exploration of the functional architecture of the active center. These studies suggest that the combination of "rigidity" and flexibility within the HuAChE gorge are an essential element of its molecular design.
Title: Function-specific blockage of M(1) and M(3) muscarinic acetylcholine receptors by VX and echothiophate Pittel Z, Barak D, Segall Y Ref: Brain Research, 1085:102, 2006 : PubMed
Certain organophosphate (OP) cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEIs) are also known to bind to the muscarinic acetylcholine receptor (mAChR). The functional consequences of such binding were investigated here using the following OP compounds: VX, echothiophate, sarin, and soman. VX (charged at physiological pH) and echothiophate (formally charged) inhibited a specific signal transduction pathway in CHO cells expressing either the M(1) or M(3) mAChR. Hence, they blocked carbamylcholine (CCh)-induced cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) synthesis (muM) and had almost no effect on CCh-induced phosphoinositide (PI) hydrolysis. These substances were inactive on forskolin-induced cAMP inhibition signaling in CHO cells expressing M(2) mAChR. In binding studies, using [(3)H]-N-methyl scopolamine ([(3)H]NMS) as the competitor ligand, the ChEIs, VX and echothiophate exhibited binding to rat cortical mAChR with K(i) values in the muM range. The non-charged compounds, sarin and soman, were inert in modulating both cAMP metabolism and PI hydrolysis in CHO cells expressing M(1), M(2), and M(3) mAChRs, and no binding was observed in presence of [(3)H]NMS. These data suggest that VX and echothiophate act as function-specific blockers via a non-classical path of antagonistic activity, implying the involvement of allosteric/ectopic-binding site in M(1) and M(3) mAChRs. The functionally selective antagonistic behavior of echothiophate and VX makes them potential tools for dissecting the interactions of the mAChR with different G proteins.
Title: Lessons from functional analysis of AChE covalent and noncovalent inhibitors for design of AD therapeutic agents Barak D, Ordentlich A, Kaplan D, Kronman C, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Chemico-Biological Interactions, 157-158:219, 2005 : PubMed
Determination of the 3D-structure of acetylcholinesterase (AChE) of Torpedo californica over a decade ago, and more recently that of human enzyme together with extensive targeted mutagenesis of the mammalian AChEs led to a fine mapping of the multiple functional domains within the active center of the enzyme. Many of the contributions of this active center architecture to accommodation of noncovalent ligands could be deduced from the X-ray structures of the corresponding HuAChE complexes. Yet, Michaelis complexes leading to transient covalent adducts are not amenable to structural analysis. Since the rates of formation of the covalent adducts depend predominantly on the stabilities of the corresponding Michaelis complexes, it is essential to characterize the specific interactions contributing to stabilization of these complexes. Functional analysis of interactions with HuAChE enzymes allows for such characterization for carbamates, like pyridostigmine or rivastigmine, much in the same way as that for the noncovalent therapeutic ligands nivalin or aricept. In fact, the observed differences between the affinities toward carbamates and the noncovalent ligands seem to result from specific structural characteristics of the inhibitors rather than from the decomposition path of the particular complex. Replacements at the cation binding site (Trp86), hydrogen bond network (Glu202, Tyr133, Glu450), and hydrophobic pocket result in similar effects for the covalent as well as for the noncovalent inhibitors. Also, while the effects of perturbing the aromatic trapping of the catalytic His447 for pyridostigmine and nivalin were analogous to those for the substrate, the corresponding effects for rivastigmine and aricept were quite different. Thus, elucidation of the functional architecture of the HuAChE active center is bound to be of considerable utility in the current effort to design novel covalent AChE inhibitors as therapeutics for Alzheimer's disease (AD).
The reactivity of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) toward the chemical warfare agent VX [O-ethyl S-[2-(diisopropylamino)ethyl] methyl-phosphonothioate] and its stereoselectivity toward the P(S)-enantiomer were investigated by examining the reactivity of HuAChE and its mutant derivatives toward purified enantiomers of VX and its noncharged isostere nc-VX [O-ethyl S-(3-isopropyl-4-methyl-pentyl) methylphosphonothioate]. Stereoselectivity of the wild-type HuAChE toward VX(S) is manifested by a 115-fold higher bimolecular rate constant (1.4 x 10(8) min(-1) M(-1)) as compared to that of VX(R). HuAChE was also 12,500-fold more reactive toward VX(S) than toward nc-VX(S), demonstrating the significance of the polar interactions of the ammonium substituent to their overall affinity toward VX. Indeed, substitution of the cation-binding subsite residue Trp86 by alanine resulted in a decrease of three orders of magnitude in HuAChE reactivity toward both VX enantiomers, with only a marginal effect on the reactivity toward the enantiomers of nc-VX. These results demonstrate that accommodation of the charged moieties of both VX enantiomers depends predominantly on interactions with the aromatic moiety of Trp86. Yet, these interactions seem to limit the stereoselectivity toward the P(S)-enantiomer, which for charged methylphosphonates is much lower than for the noncharged analogs, like sarin or soman. Marked decrease in stereoselectivity toward VX(S) was observed following replacements of Phe295 at the acyl pocket (F295A and F295A/F297A). Replacement of the peripheral anionic site (PAS) residue Asp74 by asparagine (D74N) practically abolished stereoselectivity toward VX(S) (a 130-fold decrease), while substitution which retained the negative charge at position 74 (D74E) had no effect. The results from kinetic studies and molecular simulations suggest that the differential reactivity toward the VX enantiomers originates predominantly from a different orientation of the charged leaving group with respect to residue Asp74. Such different orientations of the charged leaving group in the HuAChE adducts of the VX enantiomers seem to be a consequence of intramolecular interactions with the bulky phosphorus alkoxy group.
Functional analysis of the HuAChE active center architecture revealed that accommodation of structurally diverse substrates and other ligands is achieved through interactions with specific subsites such as the acyl pocket, cation binding site, hydrophobic site or the oxyanion hole. Recent studies have begun to unravel the role of this active center architecture in maintaining the optimal catalytic facility of the enzyme through inducing proper alignment of the catalytic triad. The exact positioning of the catalytic glutamate (Glu334) seems to be determined by a hydrogen bond network including several polar residues and water molecules. Disruption of this network by replacement of Ser229 by alanine is thought to remove the Glu334 carboxylate from the vicinity of His447 abolishing catalytic activity. The proper orientation of the catalytic histidine side chain is maintained by these polar interactions as well as through "aromatic trapping" by residues lining the HuAChE active center gorge. Thus, replacement of aromatic residues in the vicinity of His447, as in the F295A/F338A or in the Y72N/Y124Q/W286A/F295L/F297V/Y337A (hexamutant which mimicks the aromatic lining of HuBChE) enzymes, resulted in a dramatic decrease in catalytic activity, which was proposed to originate from catalytically nonproductive mobility of His447. Yet, HuBChE is catalytically efficient indicating that "aromatic trapping" is not the only way to conformationally stabilize the His447 side chain. A possible restriction of this mobility in a series of F295X/F338A HuAChEs was examined in silico followed by site-directed mutagenesis. Both simulations and reactivities of the actual F295X/F338A enzymes, carrying various aliphatic residues at position 295, indicate that of the bulky amino acids, like leucine or isoleucine, only methionine was capable of maintaining the catalytically viable conformation of His447. The F295M/F338A HuAChE was only two-fold less reactive than the F338A enzyme toward acetylthiocholine, and exhibited wild type-like reactivity toward covalent modifiers of the catalytic Ser203. The findings are consistent with the notion that different combinations of steric interference and specific polar interactions serve to maintain the position of His447 and thereby the high efficiency of the catalytic machinery. The two seemingly conflicting demands on the architecture of the active center-flexible accommodation of substrate and optimal juxtaposition of residues of the catalytic triad, demonstrate the truly amazing molecular design of the AChE active center.
Title: Poster (23) Phosphorylation and aging of AChE - insights from mutagenesis, mass spectrometry and structural studies Barak D, Ordentlich A, Kaplan D, Elhanani E, Segall Y, Barak R, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In: Cholinesterases in the Second Millennium: Biomolecular and Pathological Aspects, (Inestrosa NC, Campos EO) P. Universidad Catolica de Chile-FONDAP Biomedicina:332, 2004 : PubMed
Replacement of both the acyl pocket residue Phe295 as well as residue Phe338, adjacent to the catalytic His447 in human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE), resulted in a 680-fold decline in catalytic activity due to conformational destabilization of the histidine side chain [Barak et al. (2002) Biochemistry 41, 8245]. A possible restriction of this catalytically nonproductive mobility of His447 in a series of F295X/F338A HuAChEs was examined in silico followed by site-directed mutagenesis. Simulations suggested that of the 12 aliphatic residues substituted at position 295, including hydrophobic and polar amino acids, only methionine was capable of maintaining the catalytically viable conformation of His447. Examination of the reactivities of the actual F295X/F338A HuAChEs showed that indeed the F295M/F338A enzyme was only 2-fold less reactive than the F338A mutant toward acetylthiocholine, while enzymes substituted by the similarly bulky residues leucine and isoleucine were catalytically impaired. Furthermore, only the F295M/F338A enzyme exhibited wild-type-like reactivity toward covalent modifiers of the catalytic Ser203 including the methylphosphonate soman and transition state analogue m-(N,N,N-trimethylammonio)trifluoroacetophenone (TMTFA), as well as a facile dealkylation of the F295M/F338A-soman adduct. A different behavior was observed for bulkier ligands which introduce a deformation in the acyl pocket, and therefore their activity seems only marginally affected by the positioning of His447. The findings emphasize the importance of the precise positioning of His447 for catalysis and indicate that, in the absence of aromatic "trapping", restriction of the histidine mobility in F295X/F338A HuAChEs requires a combination of steric interference and a specific polar interaction. The results also underscore the role of the acyl pocket subsite of cholinesterases in maintaining the catalytically viable conformation of the catalytic histidine.
Title: Attempts to engineer an enzyme mimic of butyrylcholinesterase by substitution of the six divergent aromatic amino acids in the active center of acetylcholinesterase. Kaplan D, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Ariel N, Kronman C, Baruch V, Shafferman A Ref: Cholinergic Mechanisms, CRC Press, :601, 2004 : PubMed
Title: Poster (21) Analysis of acetylcholinesterase adducts of alzheimer's drugs Ordentlich A, Kronman C, Barak D, Ariel N, Kaplan D, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In: Cholinesterases in the Second Millennium: Biomolecular and Pathological Aspects, (Inestrosa NC, Campos EO) P. Universidad Catolica de Chile-FONDAP Biomedicina:332, 2004 : PubMed
The origins of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) reactivity toward the lethal chemical warfare agent O-ethyl S-[2-(diisopropylamino)ethyl] methylphosphonothioate (VX) and its stereoselectivity toward the P(S)-VX enantiomer (VX(S)) were investigated by examining the reactivity of HuAChE and its mutant derivatives toward purified enantiomers of VX and its noncharged isostere O-ethyl S-(3-isopropyl-4-methylpentyl) methylphosphonothioate (nc-VX) as well as echothiophate and its noncharged analogue. Reactivity of wild-type HuAChE toward VX(S) was 115-fold higher than that toward VX(R), with bimolecular rate constants of 1.4 x 10(8) and 1.2 x 10(6) min(-1) M(-1). HuAChE was also 12500-fold more reactive toward VX(S) than toward nc-VX(S). Substitution of the cation binding subsite residue Trp86 with alanine resulted in a 3 order of magnitude decrease in HuAChE reactivity toward both VX enantiomers, while this replacement had an only marginal effect on the reactivity toward the enantiomers of nc-VX and the noncharged echothiophate. These results attest to the critical role played by Trp86 in accommodating the charged moieties of both VX enantiomers. A marked decrease in stereoselectivity toward VX(S) was observed following replacements of Phe295 at the acyl pocket (F295A and F295A/F297A). Replacement of the peripheral anionic site (PAS) residue Asp74 with asparagine (D74N) practically abolished stereoselectivity toward VX(S) (130-fold decrease), while a substitution which retains the negative charge at position 74 (D74E) had no effect. The results from kinetic studies and molecular simulations suggest that the differential reactivity toward the VX enantiomers is mainly a result of a different interaction of the charged leaving group with Asp74.
Title: The aromatic trapping of histidine 447 in catalysis of acetylcholinesterases Shafferman A, Barak D, Kaplan D, Ordentlich A, Ariel N, Velan B Ref: In: Cholinesterases in the Second Millennium: Biomolecular and Pathological Aspects, (Inestrosa NC, Campos EO) P. Universidad Catolica de Chile-FONDAP Biomedicina:181 , 2004 : PubMed
Title: Poster (14) The aromatic trapping of histidine 447 in catalysis of acetylcholinesterases Shafferman A, Barak D, Kaplan D, Ordentlich A, Ariel N, Velan B Ref: In: Cholinesterases in the Second Millennium: Biomolecular and Pathological Aspects, (Inestrosa NC, Campos EO) P. Universidad Catolica de Chile-FONDAP Biomedicina:327, 2004 : PubMed
While substitution of the aromatic residues (Phe295, Phe338), located in the vicinity of the catalytic His447 in human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) had little effect on catalytic activity, simultaneous replacement of both residues by aliphatic amino acids resulted in a 680-fold decrease in catalytic activity. Molecular simulations suggested that the activity decline is related to conformational destabilization of His447, similar to that observed for the hexamutant HuAChE which mimics the active center of butyrylcholinesterase. On the basis of model structures of other cholinesterases (ChEs), we predicted that catalytically nonproductive mobility of His447 could be restricted by introduction of aromatic residue in a different location adjacent to this histidine (Val407). Indeed, the F295A/F338A/V407F enzyme is 170-fold more reactive than the corresponding double mutant and only 3-fold less reactive than the wild-type HuAChE. However, analogous substitution of Val407 in the hexamutant HuAChE (generating the heptamutant Y72N/Y124Q/W286A/F295L/F297V/Y337A/V407F) did not enhance catalytic activity. Reactivity of these double, triple, hexa, and hepta mutant HuAChEs was monitored toward covalent ligands such as organophosphates and the transition state analogue TMFTA, which probe, respectively, the facility of the enzymes to accommodate Michaelis complexes and to undergo the acylation process. The findings suggest that in the F295A/F338A mutant the two His447 conformational states, which are essential for the different stages of the catalytic process, seem to be destabilized. On the other hand, in the F295A/F338A/V407F mutant only the state involved in acylation is impaired. Such differential effects on the His447 conformational properties demonstrate the general role of aromatic residues in cholinesterases, and probably in other serine hydrolases, in "trapping" of the catalytic histidine and thereby in optimization of catalytic activity.
Title: Does butyrylization of acetylcholinesterase through substitution of the six divergent aromatic amino acids in the active center gorge generate an enzyme mimic of butyrylcholinesterase? Kaplan D, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Ariel N, Kronman C, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Biochemistry, 40:7433, 2001 : PubMed
The active center gorge of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) is lined by 14 aromatic residues, whereas in the closely related human butyrylcholinesterase (HuBChE) 3 of the aromatic active center residues (Phe295, Phe297, Tyr337) as well as 3 of the residues at the gorge entrance (Tyr72, Tyr124, Trp286) are replaced by aliphatic amino acids. To investigate whether this structural variability can account for the reactivity differences between the two enzymes, gradual replacement of up to all of the 6 aromatic residues in HuAChE by the corresponding residues in HuBChE was carried out. The affinities of the hexamutant (Y72N/Y124Q/W286A/F295L/F297V/Y337A) toward tacrine, decamethonium, edrophonium, huperzine A, or BW284C51 differed by about 5-, 80-, 170-, 25000-, and 17000-fold, respectively, from those of the wild-type HuAChE. For most of these prototypical noncovalent active center and peripheral site ligands, the hexamutant HuAChE displayed a reactivity phenotype closely resembling that of HuBChE. These results support the accepted view that the active center architectures of AChE and BChE differ mainly by the presence of a larger void space in BChE. Nevertheless, reactivity of the hexamutant HuAChE toward the substrates acetylthiocholine and butyrylthiocholine, or covalent ligands such as phosphonates and the transition state analogue m-(N,N,N-trimethylammonio)trifluoroacetophenone (TMTFA), is about 45-170-fold lower than that of HuBChE. Most of this reduction in reactivity can be related to the combined replacements of the three aromatic residues at the active center, Phe295, Phe297, and Tyr337. We propose that the hexamutant HuAChE, unlike BChE, is impaired in its capacity to accommodate certain tetrahedral species in the active center. This impairment may be related to the enhanced mobility of the catalytic histidine His447, which is observed in molecular dynamics simulations of the hexamutant and the F295L/F297V/Y337A HuAChE enzymes but not in the wild-type HuAChE.
Acetylcholinesterases (AChEs) form conjugates with certain highly toxic organophosphorus (OP) agents that become gradually resistant to reactivation. This phenomenon termed "aging" is a major factor limiting the effectiveness of therapy in certain cases of OP poisoning. While AChE adducts with phosphonates and phosphates are known to age through scission of the alkoxy C-O bond, the aging path for adducts with phosphoroamidates (P-N agents) like the nerve agent N,N-dimethylphosphonocyanoamidate (tabun) is not clear. Here we report that conjugates of tabun and of its butyl analogue (butyl-tabun) with the E202Q and F338A human AChEs (HuAChEs) age at similar rates to that of the wild-type enzyme. This is in marked contrast to the large effect of these substitutions on the aging of corresponding adducts with phosphates and phosphonates, suggesting that a different aging mechanism may be involved. Both tabun and butyl-tabun appear to be similarly accommodated in the active center, as suggested by molecular modeling and by kinetic studies of phosphylation and aging with a series of HuAChE mutants (E202Q, F338A, F295A, F297A, and F295L/F297V). Mass spectrometric analysis shows that HuAChE adduct formation with tabun and butyl-tabun occurs through loss of cyanide and that during the aging process both of these adducts show a mass decrease of 28 +/- 4 Da. Due to the nature of the alkoxy substituent, such mass decrease can be unequivocally assigned to loss of the dimethylamino group, at least for the butyl-tabun conjugate. This is the first demonstration that AChE adducts with toxic P-N agents can undergo aging through scission of the P-N bond.
Structures of recombinant wild-type human acetylcholinesterase and of its E202Q mutant as complexes with fasciculin-II, a 'three-finger' polypeptide toxin purified from the venom of the eastern green mamba (Dendroaspis angusticeps), are reported. The structure of the complex of the wild-type enzyme was solved to 2.8 A resolution by molecular replacement starting from the structure of the complex of Torpedo californica acetylcholinesterase with fasciculin-II and verified by starting from a similar complex with mouse acetylcholinesterase. The overall structure is surprisingly similar to that of the T. californica enzyme with fasciculin-II and, as expected, to that of the mouse acetylcholinesterase complex. The structure of the E202Q mutant complex was refined starting from the corresponding wild-type human acetylcholinesterase structure, using the 2.7 A resolution data set collected. Comparison of the two structures shows that removal of the charged group from the protein core and its substitution by a neutral isosteric moiety does not disrupt the functional architecture of the active centre. One of the elements of this architecture is thought to be a hydrogen-bond network including residues Glu202, Glu450, Tyr133 and two bridging molecules of water, which is conserved in other vertebrate acetylcholinesterases as well as in the human enzyme. The present findings are consistent with the notion that the main role of this network is the proper positioning of the Glu202 carboxylate relative to the catalytic triad, thus defining its functional role in the interaction of acetylcholinesterase with substrates and inhibitors.
Organophosphorus acid anhydride (OP) nerve agents are potent inhibitors which rapidly phosphonylate acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and then may undergo an internal dealkylation reaction (called "aging") to produce an OP-enzyme conjugate that cannot be reactivated. To understand the basis for irreversible inhibition, we solved the structures of aged conjugates obtained by reaction of Torpedo californica AChE (TcAChE) with diisopropylphosphorofluoridate (DFP), O-isopropylmethylphosponofluoridate (sarin), or O-pinacolylmethylphosphonofluoridate (soman) by X-ray crystallography to 2.3, 2.6, or 2.2 A resolution, respectively. The highest positive difference density peak corresponded to the OP phosphorus and was located within covalent bonding distance of the active-site serine (S200) in each structure. The OP-oxygen atoms were within hydrogen-bonding distance of four potential donors from catalytic subsites of the enzyme, suggesting that electrostatic forces significantly stabilize the aged enzyme. The active sites of aged sarin- and soman-TcAChE were essentially identical and provided structural models for the negatively charged, tetrahedral intermediate that occurs during deacylation with the natural substrate, acetylcholine. Phosphorylation with DFP caused an unexpected movement in the main chain of a loop that includes residues F288 and F290 of the TcAChE acyl pocket. This is the first major conformational change reported in the active site of any AChE-ligand complex, and it offers a structural explanation for the substrate selectivity of AChE.
The stereoselectivity of the phosphonylation reaction and the effects of adduct configuration on the aging process were examined for human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) and its selected active center mutants, using the four stereomers of 1,2,2-trimethylpropyl methylphosphonofluoridate (soman). The reactivity of wild type HuAChE toward the PS-soman diastereomers was 4.0-7.5 x 10(4)-fold higher than that toward the PR-diastereomers. Aging of the PSCS-somanyl-HuAChE conjugate was also >1.6 x 10(4)-fold faster than that of the corresponding PRCS-somanyl adduct, as shown by both reactivation and electrospray mass spectrometry (ESI/MS) experiments. On the other hand, both processes exhibited very limited sensitivity to the chirality of the alkoxy group Calpha of either PS- or PR-diastereomers. These stereoselectivities presumably reflect the relative participation of the enzyme in stabilization of the Michaelis complexes and in dealkylation of the respective covalent conjugates, and therefore could be utilized for further probing of the HuAChE active center functional architecture. Reactivities of HuAChE enzymes carrying replacements at the acyl pocket (F295A, F297A, and F295L/F297V) indicate that stereoselectivity with respect to the soman phosphorus chirality depends on the structure of this binding subsite, but this stereoselectivity cannot be explained only by limitation in the capacity to accommodate the PR-diastereomers. In addition, these acyl pocket enzyme mutants display some (5-10-fold) preference for the PRCR-soman over the PRCS-stereomer, while reactivity of the hydrophobic pocket mutant enzyme W86F toward the PRCS-soman resembles that of the wild type HuAChE. Residue substitutions in the H-bond network (E202Q, E450A, Y133F, and Y133A) and the hydrophobic pocket (F338A, W86A, W86F, and Y337A) result in a limited stereoselectivity for the PSCS- over the PSCR-stereomer. Aging of the PS-somanyl conjugates with all the HuAChE mutant enzymes tested practically lacked stereoselectivity with respect to the Calpha of the alkoxy moiety. Thus, the inherent asymmetry of the active center does not seem to affect the rate-determining step of the dealkylation process, possibly because both the PSCS- and the PSCR-somanyl moieties yield the same carbocationic intermediate.
Determination of the three dimensional structure of Torpedo Californica acetylcholinesterase (TcAChE) provided an experimental tool for directly visualizing interaction of AChE with cholinesterase inhibitors of fundamental, pharmacological and toxicological interest. The structure revealed that the active site is located near the bottom of a deep and narrow gorge lined with 14 conserved aromatic amino acids. The structure of a complex of TcAChE with the powerful 'transition state analog' inhibitor, TMTFA, suggested that its orientation in the experimentally determined structure was very similar to that proposed for the natural substrate, acetylcholine, by manual docking. The array of enzyme-ligand interactions visualized in the TMFTA complex also are expected to envelope the unstable TI that forms with acetylcholine during acylation, and to sequester it from solvent. In our most recent studies, the crystal structures of several 'aged' conjugates of TcAChE obtained with OP nerve agents have been solved and compared with that of the native enzyme. The methylphosphonylated-enzyme obtained by reaction with soman provides a useful structural analog for the TI that forms during deacylation after the reaction of TcAChE with acetylcholine. By comparing these structures, we conclude that the same 'oxyanion hole' residues, as well as the aromatic side chains constituting the 'acyl pocket', participate in acylation (TMTFA-AChE) and deacylation (OP-AChE), and that AChE can accommodate both TIs at the bottom of the gorge without major conformational movements.
Title: Compatibility of Structures Inferred from Mutagenesis and from X-Ray Crystallography for Various AChE Complexes Ariel N, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Bino T, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:375, 1998 : PubMed
Title: Structural Modifications of the Omega Loop in Human Acetylcholinesterase Ariel N, Velan B, Barak D, Leitner M, Bino T, Ordentlich A, Shafferman A Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:453, 1998 : PubMed
Title: The 'aromatic patch' of three proximal residues in the human acetylcholinesterase active centre allows for versatile interaction modes with inhibitors Ariel N, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Bino T, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Biochemical Journal, 335:95, 1998 : PubMed
The role of the functional architecture of the human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) active centre in accommodating the non-covalent inhibitors tacrine and huperzine A, or the carbamates pyridostigmine and physostigmine, was analysed using 16 mutants of residues lining the active-centre gorge. Despite the structural diversity of the ligands, certain common properties of the complexes could be observed: (a) replacement of aromatic residues Tyr133, Tyr337 and especially Trp86, resulted in pronounced changes in stability of all the complexes examined; (b) effects due to replacements of the five other aromatic residues along the active-centre gorge, such as the acyl pocket (Phe295, Phe297) or at the peripheral anionic site (Tyr124, Trp286, Tyr341) were relatively small; (c) effects due to substitution of the carboxylic residues in the gorge (Glu202, Glu450) were moderate. These results and molecular modelling indicate that the aromatic side chains of residues Trp86, Tyr133 and Tyr337 form together a continuous 'aromatic patch' lining the wall of the active-centre gorge, allowing for the accommodation of the different ligands via multiple modes of interaction. Studies with HuAChE mutants carrying replacements at positions 86, 133 and 337 indicate that the orientations of huperzine A and tacrine in the HuAChE complexes in solution are significantly different from those observed in X-ray structures of the corresponding complexes with Torpedo californica AChE (TcAChE). These discrepancies may be explained in terms of structural differences between the complexes of HuAChE and TcAChE or, more likely, by the enhanced flexibility of the AChE active-centre gorge in solution as compared with the crystalline state.
Title: The Aromatic Moiety at Position-86 of HuAChE Accelerate the Aging of Phosphonyl-AChE Conjugates through Cation- Interactions Barak D, Ordentlich A, Stein D, Segall Y, Velan B, Benschop HP, De Jong LP, Shafferman A Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:246, 1998 : PubMed
Title: Does Electrostatic Attraction or Steering by Charged Residues within the Gorge Contribute to the Reactivity of AChE? Ordentlich A, Barak D, Stein D, Berman D, Kronman C, Ariel N, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:234, 1998 : PubMed
Title: ESMS as a Unique Tool for the Molecular Monitoring of Reactions between HuAChE and Various OP-Agents Ordentlich A, Barak R, Barak D, Fischer M, Benschop HP, De Jong LP, Segall Y, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:249, 1998 : PubMed
The contribution of the oxyanion hole to the functional architecture and to the hydrolytic efficiency of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) was investigated through single replacements of its elements, residues Gly-121, Gly-122 and the adjacent residue Gly-120, by alanine. All three substitutions resulted in about 100-fold decrease of the bimolecular rate constants for hydrolysis of acetylthiocholine; however, whereas replacements of Gly-120 and Gly-121 affected only the turnover number, mutation of residue Gly-122 had an effect also on the Michaelis constant. The differential behavior of the G121A and G122A enzymes was manifested also toward the transition state analog m-(N,N, N-trimethylammonio)trifluoroacetophenone (TMTFA), organophosphorous inhibitors, carbamates, and toward selected noncovalent active center ligands. Reactivity of both mutants toward TMTFA was 2000-11, 000-fold lower than that of the wild type HuAChE; however, the G121A enzyme exhibited a rapid inhibition pattern, as opposed to the slow binding kinetics shown by the G122A enzyme. For both phosphates (diethyl phosphorofluoridate, diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate, and paraoxon) and phosphonates (sarin and soman), the decrease in inhibitory activity toward the G121A enzyme was very substantial (2000-6700-fold), irrespective of size of the alkoxy substituents on the phosphorus atom. On the other hand, for the G122A HuAChE the relative decline in reactivity toward phosphonates (500-460-fold) differed from that toward the phosphates (12-95-fold). Although formation of Michaelis complexes with substrates does not seem to involve significant interaction with the oxyanion hole, interactions with this motif are a major stabilizing element in accommodation of covalent inhibitors like organophosphates or carbamates. These observations and molecular modeling suggest that replacements of residues Gly-120 or Gly-121 by alanine alter the structure of the oxyanion hole motif, abolishing the H-bonding capacity of residue at position 121. These mutations weaken the interaction between HuAChE and the various ligands by 2.7-5.0 kcal/mol. In contrast, variations in reactivity due to replacement of residue Gly 122 seem to result from steric hindrance at the active center acyl pocket
Title: Contribution of the Active Center Functional Architecture to AChE Reactivity Toward Substrates and Inhibitors Shafferman A, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Kronman C, Ariel N, Velan B Ref: In: Structure and Function of Cholinesterases and Related Proteins - Proceedings of Sixth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Quinn, D.M., Rotundo, R.L., Gentry, M.K. Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:203, 1998 : PubMed
While non-reactivability of cholinesterases from their phosphyl conjugates (aging) is attributed to an unimolecular process involving loss of alkyl group from the phosphyl moiety, no conclusive evidence is available that this is the only reaction path and involvement of other post-inhibitory processes cannot be ruled out. To address this issue, molecular masses of the bacterially expressed recombinant human acetylcholinesterase and of its conjugates with a homologous series of alkyl methylphosphonofluoridates, were measured by electrospray-ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS). The measured mass of the free enzyme was 64,700 Da (calculated 64,695 Da) and those of the methylphosphono-HuAChE adducts, bearing isopropyl, isobutyl, 1,2-dimethylpropyl and 1,2,2-trimethylpropyl substituents, were 64,820, 64,840, 64,852 and 64,860 Da, respectively. These values reflect both the addition of the phosphonyl moiety and the gradual mass increase due to branching of the alkoxy substituent. The composition of these adducts change with time to yield a common product with molecular mass of 64,780 Da which is consistent with dealkylation of the phosphonyl moieties. Furthermore, in the case of 1,2-dimethylpropyl methylphosphono-HuAChE, the change in the molecular mass and the kinetics of non-reactivability appear to occur in parallel indicating that dealkylation is indeed the predominant molecular transformation leading to 'aging' of phosphonyl-AChE adducts.
Title: Interactions of oxime reactivators with diethylphosphoryl adducts of human acetylcholinesterase and its mutant derivatives Grosfeld H, Barak D, Ordentlich A, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Molecular Pharmacology, 50:639, 1996 : PubMed
Diethylphosphoryl conjugates of human acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and selected mutants, carrying amino acid replacements at the active center and at the peripheral anionic site, were subjected to reactivation with the monopyridinium oxime 2-hydroxy-iminomethyl-1-methylpyridinium chloride and the bispyridinium oximes 1,3-bis(4'-hydroxyiminomethyl-1'-pyridinium),propane dibromide (TMB-4(Trimedoxime)) and 1-(2'-hydroxyiminomethyl-1'-pyridinium)-3-(4"-carbamoyl-1"-pyridinium)-2 - oxapropane dichloride (HI-6). The kinetic profiles for all of the reactivation reactions indicate single populations of reactivatable species. Replacement of Trp86, the anionic subsite in the active center, lowered the affinity of the free enzyme toward all three reactivators, but in the corresponding diethylphosphoryl conjugate, only affinity toward TMB-4(Trimedoxime) was affected. Replacement of other constituents of the hydrophobic subsite (Tyr337, Phe338) had no major effect on either affinity to the free enzymes or rates of reactivation. Substitution of residues of the acyl pocket (Phe295, Phe297) lowered the affinities toward reactivators except for the 20-fold increase in affinity of F295A toward HI-6. Replacement of the acidic residues in the active center (Glu202, Glu450) affected mainly the rates of nucleophilic displacement of the phosphoryl moiety. The effect of substituting residues constituting the peripheral anionic site at the rim of the active site gorge (Tyr72, Asp74, Trp286) was particularly puzzling because for 2-hydroxy-iminomethyl-1-methylpyridinium chloride and HI-6, mainly the nucleophilic reaction rate constants were affected, whereas for TMB-4(Trimedoxime), the affinities of the phosphorylated enzymes were significantly reduced. The fact that perturbations of the functional architecture of HuAChE active center can account for only some of the observed effects on the reactivation rates suggests that the binding modes of oxime to the phosphorylated and nonphosphorylated enzymes are considerably different and/or that interactions of the reactivators with the phosphoryl moieties play a dominant role in the reactivation process.
The role of the functional architecture of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) active center in facilitating reactions with organophosphorus inhibitors was examined by a combination of site-directed mutagenesis and kinetic studies of phosphorylation with organophosphates differing in size of their alkoxy substituents and in the nature of the leaving group. Replacements of residues Phe-295 and Phe-297, constituting the HuAChE acyl pocket, increase up to 80-fold the reactivity of the enzymes toward diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate, diethyl phosphorofluoridate, and p-nitrophenyl diethyl phosphate (paraoxon), indicating the role of this subsite in accommodating the phosphate alkoxy substituent. On the other hand, a decrease of up to 160-fold in reactivity was observed for enzymes carrying replacements of residues Tyr-133, Glu-202, and Glu-450, which are constituents of the hydrogen bond network in the HuAChE active center, which maintains its unique functional architecture. Replacement of residues Trp-86, Tyr-337, and Phe-338 in the alkoxy pocket affected reactivity toward diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate and paraoxon, but to a lesser extent that toward diethyl phosphorofluoridate, indicating that both the alkoxy substituent and the p-nitrophenoxy leaving group interact with this subsite. In all cases the effects on reactivity toward organophosphates, demonstrated in up to 10,000-fold differences in the values of bimolecular rate constants, were mainly a result of altered affinity of the HuAChE mutants, while the apparent first order rate constants of phosphorylation varied within a narrow range. This finding indicates that the main role of the functional architecture of HuAChE active center in phosphorylation is to facilitate the formation of enzyme-inhibitor Michaelis complexes and that this affinity, rather than the nucleophilic activity of the enzyme catalytic machinery, is a major determinant of HuAChE reactivity toward organophosphates.
Title: Aging of phosphylated human acetylcholinesterase: catalytic processes mediated by aromatic and polar residues of the active centre Shafferman A, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Stein D, Ariel N, Velan B Ref: Biochemical Journal, 318:833, 1996 : PubMed
We have examined the effects of 11 substitutions of active centre gorge residues of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) on the rates of phosphonylation by 1,2,2-trimethylpropyl methyl-phosphonofluoridate (soman) and the aging of the resulting conjugates. The rates of phosphonylation were reduced to as little as one-seventieth, mainly in mutants of the hydrogen-bond network (Glu-202, Glu-450, Tyr-133). These recombinant enzymes as well as the F338A, W86A, W86F and D74N mutant HuAChEs varied in their resistance to aging (15-3300-fold relative to the wild type). The most dramatic resistance to aging was observed for the phosphonyl conjugate of the mutant W86A enzyme (1850-3300-fold relative to the wild type). It is proposed that Trp-86 contributes to the aging process by stabilizing the evolving carbonium ion on the 1,2,2-trimethylpropyl moiety, via charge-pi interaction. The rate-enhancing effect of Trp-86 provides a rationale for the unique facility of aging in soman-inhibited cholinesterases, compared with the corresponding conjugates in other serine hydrolases. Replacements of Glu-202 by aspartic acid, glutamine or alanine residues resulted in a similar (1/130-1/300) decrease of the rates of aging. A comparable decrease was also observed for the conjugate of the F338A mutant. These results, and the similar pH dependence of aging rates for the wild-type and E202Q and F338A mutant HuAChEs, indicate that Glu-202 is not involved in proton transfer to the phosphonyl moiety. On the basis of these findings and of molecular modelling we suggest that Glu-202 and Phe-338 contribute to the aging process by stabilizing the imidazolium of the catalytic triad His-447 via charge-charge and charge-pi interactions respectively, thereby facilitating an oxonium formation on the phosphonyl moiety.
Conformational mobility of the surface omega loop (Cys-69-Cys-96) in human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) was recently implicated in substrate accessibility to the active center and in the mechanism of allosteric modulation of enzymatic activity. We therefore generated and kinetically evaluated the following modifications or replacements in HuAChE: (a) residues at the loop ends, (b) residues involved in putative hydrogen-bond interactions within the loop and between the loop and the protein core, (c) ChEs conserved proline residues within the loop and (d) a deletion of a conserved segment of 5 residues. All the residue replacements, including those of the prolines, had either limited or no effect on enzyme reactivity. These results suggest that unlike the case of lipase, the omega loop in the HuAChE is not involved in large lid-like displacements. In cases where modifications of the loop sequence had some effect on reactivity, the effects could be attributed to an altered position of residue Trp-86 supporting the proposed coupling between the structure of the omega loop and the positioning of the Trp-86 indole moiety, in catalytic activity and in allosterism.
Title: Electrostatic Attraction by Surface Charge does not Contribute to the Catalytic Efficiency of Acetylcholinesterase Barak D, Ordentlich A, Kronman C, Ber R, Bino T, Ariel N, Osman R, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In Enzyme of the Cholinesterase Family - Proceedings of Fifth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Quinn, D.M., Balasubramanian, A.S., Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:223, 1995 : PubMed
Replacement of residues Asp74, Trp286, and Tyr72, which are constituents of the peripheral anionic site (PAS) of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE), affected similarly both the binding and the inhibition constants of the PAS-specific ligand propidium, demonstrating that changes in the inhibitory activity are a direct consequence of altered binding to the PAS. In contrast, the active center HuAChE mutants W86A and Y133A show respective 350- and 25-fold increased resistance to inhibition by propidium but no change in binding affinities, demonstrating that the allosteric mechanism of PAS-mediated inhibition involves a conformational change of these Trp86 and Tyr133 residues rather than physical obstruction of substrate access by the inhibitor itself. These findings support the recent proposal that the allosteric mechanism operates via transition between active and nonactive conformations of the anionic subsite Trp86 and that replacement of Tyr133 by alanine may stabilize a nonactive Trp86 conformation that occludes the active center [Ordentlich et al. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 2082]. In further support of this mechanism and the role of Tyr133, we find that (a) the dissociation constants (Kd) for the noncovalent complexes of the irreversible inhibitors diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate or paraoxon with Y133A HuAChE are increased 20-500-fold, relative to either wild-type enzyme or its Y133F or W86A mutants; and (b) access of substrates such as 3,3-dimethylbutyl thioacetate is restored by removal of Trp86 from the Y133A enzyme (i.e., the W86A/Y133A mutant). We suggest that the conformational transition of Trp86 is coupled to the motions of the cysteine loop (Cys69-Cys96) of HuAChE and is inherent to the dynamics of the native enzyme.
Title: Amino Acids Determining Specificity to OP-Agents and Facilitating the Aging Process in Human Acetylcholinesterase Ordentlich A, Kronman C, Stein D, Ariel N, Reuveny S, Marcus D, Segall Y, Barak D, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: In Enzyme of the Cholinesterase Family - Proceedings of Fifth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Quinn, D.M., Balasubramanian, A.S., Doctor, B.P., Taylor, P., Eds) Plenum Publishing Corp.:221, 1995 : PubMed
Title: Contribution of aromatic moieties of tyrosine 133 and of the anionic subsite tryptophan 86 to catalytic efficiency and allosteric modulation of acetylcholinesterase Ordentlich A, Barak D, Kronman C, Ariel N, Segall Y, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Journal of Biological Chemistry, 270:2082, 1995 : PubMed
Substitution of Trp-86, in the active center of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE), by aliphatic but not by aromatic residues resulted in a several thousandfold decrease in reactivity toward charged substrate and inhibitors but only a severalfold decrease for noncharged substrate and inhibitors. The W86A and W86E HuAChE enzymes exhibit at least a 100-fold increase in the Michaelis-Menten constant or 100-10,000-fold increase in inhibition constants toward various charged inhibitors, as compared to W86F HuAChE or the wild type enzyme. On the other hand, replacement of Glu-202, the only acidic residue proximal to the catalytic site, by glutamine resulted in a nonselective decrease in reactivity toward charged and noncharged substrates or inhibitors. Thus, the quaternary nitrogen groups of substrates and other active center ligands, are stabilized by cation-aromatic interaction with Trp-86 rather than by ionic interactions, while noncharged ligands appear to bind to distinct site(s) in HuAChE. Analysis of the Y133F and Y133A HuAChE mutated enzymes suggests that the highly conserved Tyr-133 plays a dual role in the active center: (a) its hydroxyl appears to maintain the functional orientation of Glu-202 by hydrogen bonding and (b) its aromatic moiety maintains the functional orientation of the anionic subsite Trp-86. In the absence of aromatic interactions between Tyr-133 and Trp-86, the tryptophan acquires a conformation that obstructs the active site leading, in the Y133A enzyme, to several hundredfold decrease in rates of catalysis, phosphorylation, or in affinity to reversible active site inhibitors. It is proposed that allosteric modulation of acetylcholinesterase activity, induced by binding to the peripheral anionic sites, proceeds through such conformational change of Trp-86 from a functional anionic subsite state to one that restricts access of substrates to the active center.
Several of the residues constituting the peripheral anionic site (PAS) in human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) were identified by a combination of kinetic studies with 19 single and multiple HuAChE mutants, fluorescence binding studies with the Trp-286 mutant, and by molecular modeling. Mutants were analyzed with three structurally distinct positively charged PAS ligands, propidium, decamethonium, and di(p-allyl-N-dimethylaminophenyl)pentane-3-one (BW284C51), as well as with selective active center inhibitors, hexamethonium and edrophonium. Single mutations of residues Tyr-72, Tyr-124, Glu-285, Trp-286, and Tyr-341 resulted in up to 10-fold increase in inhibition constants for PAS ligands, whereas for multiple mutants up to 400-fold increase was observed. The 6th PAS element residue Asp-74 is unique in its ability to affect conformation of both the active site and the PAS (Shafferman, A., Velan, B., Ordentlich, A., Kronman, C., Grosfeld, H., Leitner, M., Flashner, Y., Cohen, S., Barak, D., and Ariel, N. (1992) EMBO J. 11, 3561-3568) as demonstrated by the several hundred-fold increase in Ki for D74N inhibition by the bisquaternary ligands decamethonium and BW284C51. Based on these studies, singular molecular models for the various HuAChE inhibitor complexes were defined. Yet, for the decamethonium complex two distinct conformations were generated, accommodating the quaternary ammonium group by interactions with either Trp-286 or with Tyr-341. We propose that the PAS consists of a number of binding sites, close to the entrance of the active site gorge, sharing residues Asp-74 and Trp-286 as a common core. Binding of ligands to these residues may be the key to the allosteric modulation of HuAChE catalytic activity. This functional degeneracy is a result of the ability of the Trp-286 indole moiety to interact either via stacking, aromatic-aromatic, or via pi-cation attractions and the involvement of the carboxylate of Asp-74 in charge-charge or H-bond interactions.
Title: The back door hypothesis for product clearance in acetylcholinesterase challenged by site-directed mutagenesis Kronman C, Ordentlich A, Barak D, Velan B, Shafferman A Ref: Journal of Biological Chemistry, 269:27819, 1994 : PubMed
The active site of acetylcholinesterase is near the bottom of a long and narrow gorge. The dimensions of the gorge and the strong electrostatic field generated by the enzyme appear inconsistent with the enzyme's high turnover rate. Consequently, a "back door" mechanism involving movement of the reaction products through a transient opening near the active center was recently suggested. We investigated this hypothesis in human acetylcholinesterase by testing mutants at key residues (Glu-84, Trp-86, Asp-131, and Val-132) located near or along the putative back door channel. The turnover rates of all mutants tested, and in particular of V132K, where the channel is expected to be sealed by salt bridge Lys-132-Glu-452, are similar to that of the wild type enzyme. This indicates that the proposed back door is not a route for product clearance from the active site gorge of acetylcholinesterase and is probably of no functional relevance to its catalytic activity.
Acetylcholinesterases (AChEs) are characterized by a high net negative charge and by an uneven surface charge distribution, giving rise to a negative electrostatic potential extending over most of the molecular surface. To evaluate the contribution of these electrostatic properties to the catalytic efficiency, 20 single- and multiple-site mutants of human AChE were generated by replacing up to seven acidic residues, vicinal to the rim of the active-center gorge (Glu84, Glu285, Glu292, Asp349, Glu358, Glu389 and Asp390), by neutral amino acids. Progressive simulated replacement of these charged residues results in a gradual decrease of the negative electrostatic potential which is essentially eliminated by neutralizing six or seven charges. In marked contrast to the shrinking of the electrostatic potential, the corresponding mutations had no significant effect on the apparent bimolecular rate constants of hydrolysis for charged and non-charged substrates, or on the Ki value for a charged active center inhibitor. Moreover, the kcat values for all 20 mutants are essentially identical to that of the wild type enzyme, and the apparent bimolecular rate constants show a moderate dependence on the ionic strength, which is invariant for all the enzymes examined. These findings suggest that the surface electrostatic properties of AChE do not contribute to the catalytic rate, that this rate is probably not diffusion-controlled and that long-range electrostatic interactions play no role in stabilization of the transition states of the catalytic process.
Rigid analogs of acetylcholine (ACh) were designed for selective actions at muscarinic receptor (mAChR) subtypes and distinct second messenger systems. AF102B, AF150, and AF151 are such rigid analogs of ACh. AF102B, AF150 and AF151 are centrally active M1 agonists. AF102B has a unique agonistic profile showing, inter alia: only part of the M1 electrophysiology of ACh and unusual binding parameters to mAChRs. AF150 and AF151 are more efficacious agonists than AF102B for M1 AChRS in rat cortex and in CHO cells stably transfected with the m1 AChR subtype. Notably, the selectivity of the new m1 agonists is reflected also by activation of select second messenger systems via distinct G-proteins. These compounds reflect a new pharmacological concept, tentatively defined as ligand-selective signaling. Thus, agonist/m1AChR complexes may activate different combinations of signaling pathways, depending on the ligand used. Rigid agonists may activate a limited repertoire of signaling systems. In various animal models for Alzheimer's disease (AD) the agonists AF102B, AF150 and AF151, exhibited positive effects on mnemomic processes and a wide safety margin. Such agonists, and especially AF102B, can be considered as a rational treatment strategy for AD.
Substrate specificity determinants of human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) were identified by combination of molecular modeling and kinetic studies with enzymes mutated in residues Trp-86, Trp-286, Phe-295, Phe-297, Tyr-337, and Phe-338. The substitution of Trp-86 by alanine resulted in a 660-fold decrease in affinity for acetythiocholine but had no effect on affinity for the isosteric uncharged substrate (3,3-dimethylbutylthioacetate). The results demonstrate that residue Trp-86 is the anionic site which binds, through cation-pi interactions, the quaternary ammonium of choline, and that of active center inhibitors such as edrophonium. The results also suggest that in the non-covalent complex, charged and uncharged substrates with a common acyl moiety (acetyl) bind to different molecular environments. The hydrophobic site for the alcoholic portion of the covalent adduct (tetrahedral intermediate) includes residues Trp-86, Tyr-337, and Phe-338, which operate through nonpolar and/or stacking interactions, depending on the substrate. Substrates containing choline but differing in the acyl moiety (acetyl, propyl, and butyryl) revealed that residues Phe-295 and Phe-297 determine substrate specificity of the acyl pocket for the covalent adducts. Phe-295 also determines substrate specificity in the non-covalent enzyme substrate complex and thus, the HuAChE F295A mutant exhibits over 130-fold increase in the apparent bimolecular rate constant for butyrylthiocholine compared with wild type enzyme. Reactivity toward specific butyrylcholinesterase inhibitors is similarly dependent on the nature of residues at positions 295 and 297. Amino acid Trp-286 at the rim of the active site "gorge" and Trp-86, in the active center, are essential elements in the mechanism of inhibition by propidium, a peripheral anionic site ligand. Molecular modeling and kinetic data suggest that a cross-talk between Trp-286 and Trp-86 can result in reorientation of Trp-86 which may then interfere with stabilization of substrate enzyme complexes. It is proposed that the conformational flexibility of aromatic residues generates a plasticity in the active center that contributes to the high efficiency of AChE and its ability to respond to external stimuli.
Recombinant human acetylcholinesterase (HuAChE) and selected mutants (E202Q, Y337A, E450A) were studied with respect to catalytic activity towards charged and noncharged substrates, phosphylation with organophosphorus (OP) inhibitors and subsequent aging of the OP-conjugates. Amino acid E450, unlike residues E202 and Y337, is not within interaction distance from the active center. Yet, the bimolecular rates of catalysis and phosphylation are 30-100 fold lower for both E450A and E202Q compared to Y337A or the wild type and in both mutants the resulting OP-conjugates show striking resistance to aging. It is proposed that a hydrogen bond network, that maintains the functional architecture of the active center, involving water molecules and residues E202 and E450, is responsible for the observed behaviour.
31P NMR spectroscopy of butyrylcholinesterase (BChE), acetylcholinesterase (AChE), and chymotrypsin (Cht) inhibited by pinacolyl methylphosphonofluoridate (soman), methylphosphonodifluoridate (MPDF), and diisopropyl phosphorofluoridate (DFP) allowed direct observation of the OP-linked moiety of aged (nonreactivatable) and nonaged organophosphorus (OP)-ChE conjugates. The 31P NMR chemical shifts of OP-ChE conjugates clearly demonstrated insertion of a P-O- bond into the active site of aged OP-ChE adducts. The OP moiety of nonaged OP-ChEs was shown to be uncharged. The OP-bound pinacolyl moiety of soman-inhibited and aged AChE was detached completely, whereas only partial dealkylation of the pinacolyl group was observed for soman-inhibited BChEs. This suggests that the latter enzyme reacted with the less active stereoisomer(s) of soman. In the case of soman-inhibited Cht, no dealkylation could be experimentally detected for any of the four stereoisomers of OP-Cht adducts. Results are consistent with the contention that the phenomenon of enzyme-catalyzed dealkylation of OP adducts of serine hydrolases strongly depends on the orientation of both the catalytic His and the carboxyl side chain of either Glu or Asp positioned next to the catalytic Ser. The denatured protein of aged OP-ChE or OP-Cht is a convenient leaving group in nucleophilic displacements of tetrahedral OP compounds despite the presence of a P-O- bond. This indicates that the unusual resistance to reactivation of the aged enzyme cannot be ascribed to simple electrostatic repulsion of an approaching nucleophile. The broadening of the 31P NMR signal of native OP-ChEs relative to that of OP-Cht is in agreement with the crystal structure of AChE, showing that the active site region of ChEs in solution resides in a deep, narrow gorge.
Title: Molecular Models for Human AChE and its Phosphonylation Products Barak D, Ariel N, Velan B Ref: In Multidisciplinary approaches to cholinesterase functions - Proceedings of Fourth International Meeting on Cholinesterases, (Shafferman, A. and Velan, B., Eds) Plenum Press, New York:195, 1992 : PubMed
Evidence for the involvement of Ser-203, His-447, and Glu-334 in the catalytic triad of human acetylcholinesterase was provided by substitution of these amino acids by alanine residues. Of 20 amino acid positions mutated so far in human acetylcholinesterase (AChE), these three were unique in abolishing detectable enzymatic activity (less than 0.0003 of wild type), yet allowing proper production, folding, and secretion. This is the first biochemical evidence for the involvement of a glutamate in a hydrolase triad (Schrag, J.D., Li, Y., Wu, M., and Cygler, M. (1991) Nature 351, 761-764), supporting the x-ray crystal structure data of the Torpedo californica acetylcholinesterase (Sussman, J.L., Harel, M., Frolow, F., Oefner, C., Goldman, A., Toker, L. and Silman, I. (1991) Science 253, 872-879). Attempts to convert the AChE triad into a Cys-His-Glu or Ser-His-Asp configuration by site-directed mutagenesis did not yield effective AChE activity. Another type of substitution, that of Asp-74 by Gly or Asn, generated an active enzyme with increased resistance to succinylcholine and dibucaine; thus mimicking in an AChE molecule the phenotype of the atypical butyrylcholinesterase natural variant (D70G mutation). Mutations of other carboxylic residues Glu-84, Asp-95, Asp-333, and Asp-349, all conserved among cholinesterases, did not result in detectable alteration in the recombinant AChE, although polypeptide productivity of the D95N mutant was considerably lower. In contrast, complete absence of secreted human AChE polypeptide was observed when Asp-175 or Asp-404 were substituted by Asn. These two aspartates are conserved in the entire cholinesterase/thyroglobulin family and appear to play a role in generating and/or maintaining the folded state of the polypeptide. The x-ray structure of the Torpedo acetylcholinesterase supports this assumption by revealing the participation of these residues in salt bridges between neighboring secondary structure elements.
Amino acids located within and around the 'active site gorge' of human acetylcholinesterase (AChE) were substituted. Replacement of W86 yielded inactive enzyme molecules, consistent with its proposed involvement in binding of the choline moiety in the active center. A decrease in affinity to propidium and a concomitant loss of substrate inhibition was observed in D74G, D74N, D74K and W286A mutants, supporting the idea that the site for substrate inhibition and the peripheral anionic site overlap. Mutations of amino acids neighboring the active center (E202, Y337 and F338) resulted in a decrease in the catalytic and the apparent bimolecular rate constants. A decrease in affinity to edrophonium was observed in D74, E202, Y337 and to a lesser extent in F338 and Y341 mutants. E202, Y337 and Y341 mutants were not inhibited efficiently by high substrate concentrations. We propose that binding of acetylcholine, on the surface of AChE, may trigger sequence of conformational changes extending from the peripheral anionic site through W286 to D74, at the entrance of the 'gorge', and down to the catalytic center (through Y341 to F338 and Y337). These changes, especially in Y337, could block the entrance/exit of the catalytic center and reduce the catalytic efficiency of AChE.
