Family Report for: Cholinesterase-like

Primary sequences of cholinesterases and related proteins have been systematically compared. The cholinesterase-like domain of these proteins, about 500 amino acids, may fulfill a catalytic and a structural function. We identified an aspartic acid residue that is conserved among esterases and lipases (Asp-397 in Torpedo acetylcholinesterase) but that had not been considered to be involved in the catalytic mechanism. Site-directed mutagenesis demonstrated that this residue is necessary for activity. Analysis of evolutionary relationships shows that the noncatalytic members of the family do not constitute a separate subgroup, suggesting that loss of catalytic activity occurred independently on several occasions, probably from bifunctional molecules. Cholinesterases may thus be involved in cell-cell interactions in addition to the hydrolysis of acetylcholine. This would explain their specific expression in well-defined territories during embryogenesis before the formation of cholinergic synapses and their presence in noncholinergic tissues.

Developing cells of Dictyostelium discoideum contain crystalline inclusion bodies. The interlattice spaces of the crystals are approximately 11 nm, and their edge dimensions vary in aggregating cells from 0.1 to 0.5 micron. The crystals are enclosed by a membrane with the characteristics of RER. To unravel the nature of the crystals we isolated them under electron microscopical control and purified the two major proteins that cofractionate with the crystals, one of an apparent molecular mass of 69 kD, the other of 56 kD. This latter protein proved to be identical with the protein encoded by the developmentally regulated D2 gene of D. discoideum, as shown by its reactivity with antibodies raised against the bacterially expressed product of a D2 fusion gene. The D2 gene is known to be strictly regulated at the transcript level and to be controlled by cAMP signals. Accordingly, very little of the 56-kD protein was detected in growth phase cells, maximal expression was observed at the aggregation stage, and the expression was stimulated by cAMP pulses. The 69-kD protein is the major constituent of the crystals and is therefore called "crystal protein." This protein is developmentally regulated and accumulates in aggregating cells similar to the D2 protein, but is not, or is only slightly regulated by cAMP pulses. mAbs specific for either the crystal protein or the D2 protein, labeled the intracellular crystals as demonstrated by the use of immunoelectron microscopy. The complete cDNA-derived amino acid sequence of the crystal protein indicates a hydrophobic leader and shows a high degree of sequence similarity with Torpedo acetylcholinesterase and rat lysophospholipase. Because the D2 protein also shows sequence similarities with various esterases, the vesicles filled with crystals of these proteins are named esterosomes.

We have previously shown that the developmentally regulated gene D2 is induced during aggregation by pulses of cAMP, which act via the cell surface receptor and consequent signal transduction pathways (W. Rowekamp and R.A. Firtel, 1980, Dev. Biol. 79, 409-418; S.K.O. Mann and R.A. Firtel, 1987, Mol. Cell. Biol. 7, 458-469; S.K.O. Mann, C. Pinko, and R.A. Firtel, 1988, Dev. Biol., in press). In this manuscript, we compare the complete derived amino acid sequence for D2 to two cloned and sequenced eukaryotic esterases and examine the requirement of the D2 gene product for development. Amino acid sequence data comparisons suggest that D2 encodes a serine esterase with strong sequence identity to Torpedo acetylcholine esterase and a Drosophila esterase. The protein has a putative leader sequence, suggesting that it is shunted into vesicles. Using an antisense gene construct driven by a Discoidin I promoter, whose transcriptional activity depends on the growth conditions of the cells, we show that inhibition of D2 mRNA accumulation results in an abnormal developmental program that includes the absence of normal streaming and incomplete aggregate formation and subsequent development. We suggest that D2 encodes an esterase function required for proper aggregation and subsequent development.

Ticks vector many pathogens with major health and economic impacts and have developed resistance to most acaricides used for tick control. Organophosphate (OP) acaricides target acetylcholinesterase (AChE) critical to tick central nervous system function. Mutations producing tick AChEs resistant to OPs were characterized; but tick OP-resistance is not fully elucidated, due to remarkable complexity of tick cholinergic systems. Three paralogous tick AChEs exhibiting differences in primary structure and biochemical kinetics are encoded by amplified genes with developmentally regulated expression. Gene silencing data suggest tick AChEs are functional complements in vivo, and transcriptomic and genomic data suggest existence of additional tick AChEs. Cholinergic systems are crucial in neural transmission and are also regulators of vertebrate immune function. Ticks exhibit prolonged intimate host contact, suggesting adaptive functions for tick cholinergic system complexity. AChE was recently reported in tick saliva and a role in manipulation of host immune responses was hypothesized. Physiological roles and genetic control of multiple tick AChEs requires further elucidation and may provide unique opportunities to understand and manipulate cholinergic involvement in biological systems.

Tight control of the concentration of acetylcholine at cholinergic synapses requires precise regulation of the number and state of the acetylcholine receptors, and of the synthesis and degradation of the neurotransmitter. In particular, the cholinesterase activity has to be controlled exquisitely. In the genome of the first experimental models used (man, mouse, zebrafish and drosophila), there are only one or two genes coding for cholinesterases, whereas there are more genes for their closest relatives the carboxylesterases. Natural amplification of cholinesterase genes was first found to occur in some cancer cells and in insect species subjected to evolutionary pressure by insecticides. Analysis of the complete genome sequences of numerous representatives of the various metazoan phyla show that moderate amplification of cholinesterase genes is not uncommon in molluscs, echinoderms, hemichordates, prochordates or lepidosauria. Amplification of acetylcholinesterase genes is also a feature of parasitic nematodes or ticks. In these parasites, over-production of cholinesterase-like proteins in secreted products and the saliva are presumed to have effector roles related to host infection. These amplification events raise questions about the role of the amplified gene products, and the adaptation processes necessary to preserve efficient cholinergic transmission. This is an article for the special issue XVth International Symposium on Cholinergic Mechanisms.

Nematodes are unusual in that diverse molecular forms of acetylcholinesterase are the product of distinct genes. This is best characterised in the free living organism Caenorhabditis elegans, in which 3 genes are known to give rise to distinct enzymes, with a fourth likely to be non-functional. ACE-1 is an amphiphilic tetramer associated with a hydrophobic non-catalytic subunit, analogous to vertebrate T enzymes, whereas ACE-2 and ACE-3 are glycosylphosphatidylinositol-linked amphiphilic dimers. The different ace genes show distinct anatomical patterns of expression in muscles, sensory neurons and motor neurons, with only a few examples of coordinated expression. Clear homologues of ace-1 and ace-2 have now been isolated from a variety of parasitic nematodes, and the predicted proteins have very similar C-terminal amino acid sequences, implying an analogous means of anchorage to membranes. In addition to these membrane-bound enzymes, many parasitic nematodes which colonise mucosal surfaces secrete acetylcholinesterases to the external (host) environment. These hydrophilic enzymes are separately encoded in the genome, so that some parasites may thus have a total complement of six ace genes. The secretory enzymes have been characterised from the intestinal nematode Nippostrongylus brasiliensis and the lungworm Dictyocaulus viviparus. These show a number of common features, including a truncated C-terminus and an insertion at the molecular surface, when compared to other nematode acetylcholinesterases. Although the function of these enzymes has not been determined, they most likely alter host physiological responses to promote survival of the parasite.

Primary sequences of cholinesterases and related proteins have been systematically compared. The cholinesterase-like domain of these proteins, about 500 amino acids, may fulfill a catalytic and a structural function. We identified an aspartic acid residue that is conserved among esterases and lipases (Asp-397 in Torpedo acetylcholinesterase) but that had not been considered to be involved in the catalytic mechanism. Site-directed mutagenesis demonstrated that this residue is necessary for activity. Analysis of evolutionary relationships shows that the noncatalytic members of the family do not constitute a separate subgroup, suggesting that loss of catalytic activity occurred independently on several occasions, probably from bifunctional molecules. Cholinesterases may thus be involved in cell-cell interactions in addition to the hydrolysis of acetylcholine. This would explain their specific expression in well-defined territories during embryogenesis before the formation of cholinergic synapses and their presence in noncholinergic tissues.

Developing cells of Dictyostelium discoideum contain crystalline inclusion bodies. The interlattice spaces of the crystals are approximately 11 nm, and their edge dimensions vary in aggregating cells from 0.1 to 0.5 micron. The crystals are enclosed by a membrane with the characteristics of RER. To unravel the nature of the crystals we isolated them under electron microscopical control and purified the two major proteins that cofractionate with the crystals, one of an apparent molecular mass of 69 kD, the other of 56 kD. This latter protein proved to be identical with the protein encoded by the developmentally regulated D2 gene of D. discoideum, as shown by its reactivity with antibodies raised against the bacterially expressed product of a D2 fusion gene. The D2 gene is known to be strictly regulated at the transcript level and to be controlled by cAMP signals. Accordingly, very little of the 56-kD protein was detected in growth phase cells, maximal expression was observed at the aggregation stage, and the expression was stimulated by cAMP pulses. The 69-kD protein is the major constituent of the crystals and is therefore called "crystal protein." This protein is developmentally regulated and accumulates in aggregating cells similar to the D2 protein, but is not, or is only slightly regulated by cAMP pulses. mAbs specific for either the crystal protein or the D2 protein, labeled the intracellular crystals as demonstrated by the use of immunoelectron microscopy. The complete cDNA-derived amino acid sequence of the crystal protein indicates a hydrophobic leader and shows a high degree of sequence similarity with Torpedo acetylcholinesterase and rat lysophospholipase. Because the D2 protein also shows sequence similarities with various esterases, the vesicles filled with crystals of these proteins are named esterosomes.

We have previously shown that the developmentally regulated gene D2 is induced during aggregation by pulses of cAMP, which act via the cell surface receptor and consequent signal transduction pathways (W. Rowekamp and R.A. Firtel, 1980, Dev. Biol. 79, 409-418; S.K.O. Mann and R.A. Firtel, 1987, Mol. Cell. Biol. 7, 458-469; S.K.O. Mann, C. Pinko, and R.A. Firtel, 1988, Dev. Biol., in press). In this manuscript, we compare the complete derived amino acid sequence for D2 to two cloned and sequenced eukaryotic esterases and examine the requirement of the D2 gene product for development. Amino acid sequence data comparisons suggest that D2 encodes a serine esterase with strong sequence identity to Torpedo acetylcholine esterase and a Drosophila esterase. The protein has a putative leader sequence, suggesting that it is shunted into vesicles. Using an antisense gene construct driven by a Discoidin I promoter, whose transcriptional activity depends on the growth conditions of the cells, we show that inhibition of D2 mRNA accumulation results in an abnormal developmental program that includes the absence of normal streaming and incomplete aggregate formation and subsequent development. We suggest that D2 encodes an esterase function required for proper aggregation and subsequent development.